This week I'm speaking at the Keiser University World Conference about funding the future workforce. While I was building the session, I kept coming back to one idea.
I didn't fully understand the replacement crisis until I left the classroom. Between December and May, I worked in integrated pest management, and I saw the hiring need firsthand. Good jobs, real careers, and not enough trained people to fill them. That's when I started digging into the workforce data, and it's a big part of why I came back to teaching.
We talk about agriculture programs like they are electives. They aren't. They're a pipeline.
And a pipeline you underfund doesn't just get smaller. It leaks.
The Jobs Are There. The Graduates Aren't.
Every five years, USDA and Purdue University publish a report on job openings for college graduates in food, agriculture, renewable natural resources, and the environment.
The most recent one projected about 59,400 openings every year from 2020 to 2025. New graduates with degrees in those fields were expected to fill only about 61 percent of them. The rest go to graduates from other fields, or they go unfilled.
And agriculture isn't shrinking. It's aging. The average American farmer is 58.1 years old, according to the 2022 Census of Agriculture. That's the replacement crisis: a wave of openings is coming whether we're ready or not.
At the same time, the programs that feed that pipeline are under strain. The 2024 National Agricultural Education Supply and Demand Study counted 236 new school-based ag programs, and 58 that closed. The share of closures blamed on insufficient funding jumped from 5 percent in 2023 to 21 percent in 2024.
More Money Didn't Mean More Stability
Here's the part that surprised me most in my research.
Between fiscal years 2018 and 2024, the national Perkins basic state grant grew from about $1.19 billion to about $1.44 billion. That's roughly a 21 percent increase.
Programs still closed.
The problem was never the amount. It was the structure. Money moved through formulas, enrollment counts, and accountability rules that didn't always reach the programs doing the work. A program could be in a well-funded state and still be one bad year away from losing its lab, its livestock, or its travel.
What Funding the Workforce Should Look Like
If we really believe ag education is a workforce pipeline, then funding it should look like funding infrastructure, not like a yearly gamble.
- Stable base funding for the core of the program, so one formula change doesn't close a barn.
- Industry partnership that goes beyond sponsorship, with SAE placements, internships, and employers on the advisory committee.
- Outcome tracking that shows where students actually go after graduation, so programs can prove their value with real numbers.
- Equity built in, so programs serving lower-income students aren't penalized by performance formulas they can't control.
What You Can Do This Month
You don't have to fix federal policy. Start local.
- Find out which agriculture employers in your county are hiring right now
- Invite one of them to visit your class or join your advisory committee
- Start a simple list of where your graduates are working or studying
Every one of those steps turns "elective" into "pipeline." And pipelines get protected.
Sources
- USDA National Institute of Food and Agriculture and Purdue University. Employment Opportunities for College Graduates in Food, Agriculture, Renewable Natural Resources, and the Environment, 2020 to 2025.
- USDA National Agricultural Statistics Service. 2022 Census of Agriculture.
- American Association for Agricultural Education and National Association of Agricultural Educators. 2024 National Agricultural Education Supply and Demand Study.
- Paterson, A. (2026). Sustaining Agricultural Education: An Archival Analysis of Funding Variability and Program Sustainability. Keiser University.
- U.S. Department of Education, Office of Career, Technical, and Adult Education. Perkins V State Allocations.
- Paterson, A. (2026). The Replacement Crisis.
From Dr. Paterson's books
Written by Dr. Amy Paterson, Ed.D., for The Rooted Ag Educator. © 2026 Dr. Amy Paterson. You are welcome to share a link to this post or quote a short passage with credit to the author.
