Start Here: What This Workbook Is
The Replacement Crisis makes the argument. Agriculture is aging, not shrinking. Our programs already produce the workforce industry says it cannot find, and almost nobody is counting or connecting any of it.
This workbook is the doing half. It assumes you are convinced and asks what you do Monday. It follows your year, not the book's argument, so you open it to the part you are standing in.
I want to be honest about the cost. When I asked teachers what gets in the way of this work, the answer came back from three states in nearly the same words: time. The front end is two class periods and a planning period. After that, it is twenty minutes at the end of each quarter. Not nothing. What it buys is that none of it comes back in full next year, because every page takes something you already carry in your head and gives it a place to live.
Here is what it is not.
Not a curriculum. It does not replace what you teach.
Not a summary of the book. If you own the workbook and not the book, everything still works.
Not an assessment system. Please hear this one. Nothing in Part One is norm-referenced or validated against employment outcomes. The survey and the battery are teaching and conversation tools. A low score means a skill has not been taught yet. That is a finding about a curriculum, not about a child. No student should ever be placed, screened, or told a door is closed because of anything in here.
What's Inside
| Part | When | Tools | What you walk away with |
|---|---|---|---|
| Part One: Find Out Who Is Actually in Your Room | August, first two weeks | 1.1 The Career Cluster Survey and 1.1b How You Like to Work; 1.2 The Aptitude Battery and 1.2b Answer Key and Composites; 1.3 Scoring and Composites; 1.4 Reading the Two Together; 1.5 The Ten Pathways (1.5a to 1.5j); 1.6 Your Class Capability Map | Every student's top two pathways, work style, and capability scores on one page |
| Part Two: Map What You Already Have | August to September, one planning period | 2.1 The Partner Audit; 2.2 The Gap Sheet; 2.3 Setting Up the Tracker; 2.4 Your Baseline Number | Partners sorted by pathway, your gaps, and your local placement rate |
| Part Three: Build the Connection | September onward | 3.1 The Small and Specific Ask; 3.2 The Semester-Ahead Calendar; 3.3 The Agenda That Fills a Gap; 3.4 The Placement Agreement; 3.5 Moving a Partner Up a Stage | Asks an employer can say yes to, timed to their season |
| Part Four: Turn It Into Placements | All year | 4.1 Name What You Can Do (lesson) and 4.1b Say What You Actually Did (student page); 4.2 SAE as Pipeline, Not Paperwork; 4.3 Making the Introduction; 4.4 Exit Tracking and Your Local 3S1 | Students who can describe their skills, real introductions, and an exit log |
| Part Five: Make the Case and Keep It | Budget season, and every year after | 5.1 The Five-Minute Admin Script; 5.2 The One-Page Leave-Behind; 5.3 Widening a Partnership; 5.4 What You Owe Them | A conversation built on a real number, and partnerships that last |
| Reference | Any time | R.1 Certifications by Pathway and Job Level; R.2 Where Credentials Come From; R.3 Verify It Locally; R.4 Glossary; R.5 Finding Your State's Numbers | Your local credential map and your state's placement number |
How the Pages Work
Every tool page has an ID strip in the top corner, like 1.2 APTITUDE BATTERY. Pull out a single page and you still know where it came from.
Anything with a line on it is meant to be written on. It is a workbook. Write in it.
References to the main book use chapter titles, not numbers. Each Part opens with a "From The Replacement Crisis" box naming the chapters behind it, so the references still work if a future edition moves things.
Read the shaded box at the bottom of each page. "Before You Turn the Page," "The One to Fix First," "Do This Before You Close the Book." That box usually carries the real instruction.
The pages feed each other. The Gap Sheet pulls from the Capability Map and the Partner Audit. The admin script pulls from your baseline and exit log.
The student instruments have a free web version. The QR code is on the back cover and at the start of Part One, and it takes you to crisis.rootedageducator.org.
Your Year, Step by Step
| When | What you do | Tools |
|---|---|---|
| August, first two weeks | Survey one day, battery the next. Score, read the two together, hand out pathway pages, fill the Capability Map. | 1.1 to 1.6 |
| Same week | Find the pathway with students and no partner. Make one four-minute call for the student who surprised you most. Put the April retest on your calendar. | 1.6 |
| August to September, one planning period | List and sort every contact, line them up against your students, count your baseline. | 2.1, 2.2, 2.4 |
| September | One afternoon setting up the tracker. Build the leave-behind. Map your local hiring seasons and set three phone reminders. | 2.3, 5.2, 3.2 |
| Fall | Build your first small ask off the gap sheet. Pull the adults out of your SAEs. Teach the Name What You Can Do lesson. | 3.1, 4.2, 4.1 |
| When a placement starts | Five-minute Placement Agreement. Put the three report-back dates in your calendar that day. | 3.4, 5.4 |
| Ongoing | Introductions with the student copied in. Run the gap agenda. Move two partners up a stage. | 4.3, 3.3, 3.5 |
| End of each quarter | About twenty minutes on the tracker. | 2.3 |
| April | Retest. | 1.1, 1.2 |
| May | Every graduating concentrator fills one exit row. Move rows into the tracker before summer. | 4.4 |
| Budget season | Five minutes with your administrator. Leave the page behind. Check for partnerships that live in one person's phone. | 5.1, 5.2, 5.3 |
| Spring | Update your certification map. Confirm last year's exit answers. | R.1, 4.4 |
Giving the Student Survey and Aptitude Battery
Together these two halves are what the book calls the Pathfinder. One asks what a student would want to do. The other asks what they can already do. Neither is enough alone.
Prep. Decide on paper or the free web version. Have pencils. No calculators needed. Keep 1.2b, the answer key, with you. It is a teacher page.
Day one: the Career Cluster Survey (1.1 and 1.1b). One class period. Forty items, then twelve about how they like to work, all scored 3 to 0. Read aloud:
"Read each line and ask one thing: would you want to spend an afternoon doing that? Not whether you would be good at it. Not whether it pays. Whether you would want to do it. Three is yes, I would look forward to that. Two is sure, that sounds fine. One is not really. Zero is no, I would dread it. Work fast. Your first reaction is more accurate than the one you talk yourself into."
For the last twelve, tell them these are not about agriculture at all. They are about what kind of day they want.
Day two: the Aptitude Battery (1.2). One class period. Thirty-five questions, seven areas, five questions each. There are right answers. Read aloud:
"This asks what you can already do. Nobody expects you to have been taught all of this. A question you cannot answer is a skill nobody has shown you yet, and that is worth knowing too. Circle the best answer, then write its letter in the box on the right. If you are unsure, make your best reasoning and move on. A blank tells me less than a wrong answer does."
Scoring the survey (1.3). Every four items belong to one pathway, in order: 1 to 4 Agribusiness, 5 to 8 Animal, on through 37 to 40 Ag Technology. Total each column. Highest total is the top pathway. Two or three close totals is normal and useful. The twelve work-style items total into Hands (S1 to S3), Data (S4 to S6), People (S7 to S9), and Plan (S10 to S12).
Scoring the battery (1.2b). One point per correct answer, added into four composites rather than seven noisy subtests: Mechanical and Electrical (1 to 10), Fabrication and Applied Math (11 to 20), Living Systems, Soil and Water (21 to 30), and Procedure and Safety (31 to 35, out of 5).
Read Procedure and Safety first. Every employer screens for it and none will train around it. It is the only composite where a low score should change what you do next: that skill gets taught before any placement, for the student's safety and yours.
Reading the two together (1.4).
- High interest, high score: go. Make an introduction this semester, not this year.
- High interest, low score: not a closed door. A teaching list. Teach it, retest in April.
- Low interest, high score: one careful conversation. Show them the pathway once. Do not push.
- Low interest, low score: leave it. Read their next pathway. There is no shortage of doors.
What to tell students (1.5). Hand each student the pages for their top and second pathway. Each shows a ladder of four levels, entry to professional, plus the credentials common there. Ask them to circle every job title they have never heard of. That list is your conversation. A student who scores highest in Animal Systems is not being told to become a veterinarian. She is being shown a ladder that starts with a barn job she could hold this summer.
Then write the employers you know in the "Who Hires Near Us" box. Leave the blanks blank. An empty box is the gap in your program.
Last step (1.6). Move every result onto the Class Capability Map: top pathway, second pathway, work style, and whether a partner stands behind it.
Using It With a Class Set
The workbook is written to you, the teacher. If you bought one copy, that is the copy it was designed for.
These pages are written to students: 1.1 and 1.1b (the survey), 1.2 (the battery), 1.3 (adding up their scores), 1.5a to 1.5j (the pathway pages you hand out), 4.1b (the handout for the 4.1 lesson), and 4.4, where each graduating concentrator fills one row.
Everything else is yours: 1.2b (marked as a teacher page, with the answer key), 1.4, 1.6, all of Parts Two, Three, and Five, the 4.1 teacher script, 4.2, 4.3, and the Reference section.
If every student gets a workbook, remember the answer key sits right after the battery. Plan for that. The free web version is another way to give both instruments to a whole class.
On copying: the workbook mentions photocopying a single page with its ID strip, and R.3 says to copy that sheet for each credential you consider. For anything beyond that, check the copyright page in your copy before you run a class set.
Turning It Into Placements and Making the Case
Part Four is the part nobody does. A capability nobody can describe is a capability nobody will hire.
Start with 4.1. One class period, and I think the highest-value hour in the workbook. "I placed second in Prepared Public Speaking" sounds like a hobby. "I researched a technical topic, presented for six minutes to a panel of adults, and answered questions I had not seen in advance" sounds like a job skill. Students write three experiences, start each with a verb, and cut every FFA-only word. Collect the handouts. You will need those lines.
Then look at your SAEs (4.2). Every placement SAE has an adult behind it who already said yes to a student once. Any name not on your partner audit goes on it today.
An introduction (4.3) is three sentences: who the student is, their strongest line in their own words, and one specific ask. Copy the student in, so they walk away with an adult's name and permission to use it.
In May, every graduating concentrator fills one exit row (4.4). Ask for a contact that will still work in two years, because the school email dies in June. Tell them why: you are counting, and they are part of the count.
Part Five is the case. You are walking in with a measurement, not a request. The script (5.1) has four beats: the number, why it is real, one current win, the ask. Fill it from your baseline and exit log. It does not work with an estimate. Keep it separate from the budget conversation, which lives in Sustaining Agricultural Education. Never run both in one meeting.
Leave one page behind (5.2), one side only, and leave your gaps on it. A page that only shows wins reads as marketing. Then protect what you built: widen any partnership that lives in one person's phone (5.3), and report back every time (5.4) with a thank-you within a week, the outcome at semester's end, and a yearly invitation to something that is not an ask.
Pro Tips From Dr. Paterson
Questions Teachers Ask
Q: Do I need The Replacement Crisis to use this?
A: No. Everything here works on its own. The book is where the evidence lives if you want the why.
Q: Can I use the survey or battery to decide who gets a placement?
A: No. They are for teaching and conversation. The only score that should change what you do is a low Procedure and Safety composite, and what it changes is what you teach before any placement.
Q: I do not use spreadsheets. Is the tracker required?
A: No. Everything in it exists on paper here: the audit at 2.1, the capability map at 1.6, the exit log at 4.4. What is required is that the information lives somewhere other than your memory, because your memory leaves the building when you do.
Q: I do not have an advisory board. Can I still run the gap agenda?
A: Yes. Five of the six teachers behind the book had no functioning board. Building one is covered in Sustaining Agricultural Education, but the agenda at 3.3 works with three people around a classroom table.
Q: What is 3S1?
A: The federal placement indicator: did a student land in postsecondary education, the military, national service, or employment. 2.4 finds your program's version. R.5 finds your state's in about twenty minutes.
Q: Why is the certification page blank?
A: Credential availability changes state by state, and a printed list is wrong somewhere the day it prints. R.1 is yours to fill, starting with the pathways on your gap sheet. R.3 gives you six questions to answer before you commit a semester.
Written by Dr. Amy Paterson, Ed.D., for The Rooted Ag Educator. © 2026 Dr. Amy Paterson. You are welcome to print this guide for your own classroom and program use.
